Dear Compassion International Leadership,
I am writing as a longtime supporter of Compassion International who is deeply troubled by the recent investigative reporting published by The Roys Report concerning child safeguarding, inappropriate sponsor correspondence, and the treatment of whistleblower Andrew Vezey.
I have followed Rebecca Hopkins's reporting and listened to Julie Roys's interview with Mr. Vezey. I understand that Compassion disputes aspects of his allegations and that AI-generated findings require careful human investigation. Nevertheless, the documented examples and reported scale of the safeguarding concerns are deeply disturbing. I am especially dismayed to learn that Compassion has filed a lawsuit against Mr. Vezey. Whatever legitimate concerns the organization may have about confidentiality, pursuing legal action against an employee who reports serious child protection concerns creates a deeply troubling appearance of retaliation.
I urge Compassion to reconsider this course of action, welcome independent scrutiny, and demonstrate through concrete, transparent measures that protecting children takes precedence over protecting the organization's reputation or preserving its existing fundraising model.
I will be watching closely to see how Compassion addresses these matters. I sincerely hope the organization responds with the humility, courage, and accountability that its Christian mission demands.
I would also like to share some reflections from my own experience, because I believe the current crisis presents an opportunity to reconsider some longstanding assumptions about child sponsorship.
My family's history with Compassion
I grew up in an evangelical Christian home where missions and charitable giving were central to our family life. My father led our family in sponsoring two Compassion children, one after the other. I still remember the name of one of those children decades later because we regularly prayed for her.
When my own daughter was five, my husband and I began sponsoring a little girl in Haiti, who was the same age as our daughter. We continued supporting her for approximately 17 years, until she graduated from the program as a young adult.
I have always appreciated Compassion's commitment to working through local churches and providing children with education, nutrition, healthcare, and Christian discipleship. I believe this work has accomplished tremendous good, and I remain grateful that our family could contribute to it.
However, over those 17 years, I became increasingly uncomfortable with the personal correspondence component of sponsorship.
The emotional burden of sponsor correspondence
Although I never hesitated to provide financial support, writing letters to our sponsored child became an ongoing source of stress and guilt.
We tried to develop a meaningful relationship through correspondence, but the long delays, translation process, and often brief or formulaic replies made genuine mutual understanding difficult. I rarely felt that we were getting to know our sponsored child as an individual, despite our sincere efforts.
Compassion's promotional materials repeatedly emphasized the extraordinary emotional significance of sponsors' letters. We were encouraged to tell children how special, loved, and valuable they were, and how much we believed in their futures.
These are wonderful things for children to hear. But I often felt that I was being asked to manufacture a degree of personal intimacy that did not actually exist.
I have since come to recognize this as a form of emotional labor. The expectation that I should continually generate affectionate, affirming correspondence with someone I barely knew was emotionally demanding, particularly while raising a young child and managing other responsibilities.
Compassion's repeated appeals for more frequent letter-writing only intensified my sense of guilt.
I suspect my experience may be considerably more common than Compassion realizes. Indeed, I was struck that Julie Roys described similar difficulties with letter-writing during her recent interview.
Has Compassion ever conducted anonymous research among both current and former sponsors to determine how they actually experience the correspondence requirement? How many find it meaningful, and how many experience it primarily as an obligation? How many former sponsors might return if offered a different model?
I believe these questions deserve serious consideration.
The emotional expectations placed upon children and their families
More importantly, I have come to question the emotional expectations placed upon sponsored children.
If letter-writing was difficult and artificial for me, might it also have been difficult for our sponsored child? Was she encouraged to express affection and gratitude toward people she barely knew because our financial contributions helped support her?
And what about her parents?
This question has become increasingly important to me through my own experience providing services to low-income families and through learning more about poverty alleviation, cultural dignity, and the unintended consequences of well-meaning charitable work.
A family's lack of economic resources does not imply a lack of emotional resources.
Parents living in poverty may be making extraordinary sacrifices to love, nurture, encourage, and protect their children. Yet the traditional sponsorship narrative often places the Western donor at the emotional center of the child's life, emphasizing the donor's supposedly unique ability to communicate love, hope, affirmation, and personal worth.
Why should the affirming words of a relatively wealthy stranger be presented as more transformative than those of a child's own parents, grandparents, teachers, pastors, and community members?
I worry that the sponsorship model can unintentionally diminish the very families it intends to help.
I also wonder whether parents always feel genuinely free to establish boundaries around their children's correspondence with foreign adults. A parent might be uncomfortable with a stranger expressing personal affection toward their child but hesitate to object because the relationship is associated with essential material assistance.
The recent safeguarding revelations make these concerns especially urgent.
Consent, privacy, and children's photographs
I am also concerned about the longstanding practice of displaying individual children's photographs and identifying information to prospective sponsors.
I appreciate that Compassion has taken steps to reduce the amount of personal information publicly shared. However, I believe the ethical questions go beyond obtaining formal parental consent.
When a family desperately needs assistance, how freely can a parent decline permission to have their child's photograph displayed to strangers if they believe that doing so might jeopardize access to nutrition, healthcare, or education?
Can parents decline the use of their child's photograph in fundraising materials without any reduction in program eligibility or benefits? Can they withdraw consent later?
In light of the documented dangers of online child exploitation, these questions deserve clear and transparent answers.
Reconsidering the original sponsorship model
I recognize that Compassion's approach to child sponsorship is deeply rooted in its history. As I understand it, Compassion began in 1952 in response to the suffering of children orphaned by the Korean War, with early sponsorship efforts supporting children living in orphanages.
I can readily understand why personal correspondence would have been particularly meaningful in that context. Children who had lost their parents and were growing up in institutional settings might have treasured letters from a family overseas expressing personal interest, affection, and encouragement. For some, such correspondence could have provided a valuable sense of belonging and individual recognition.
But the population Compassion serves today is dramatically different. Most sponsored children are not orphans living in institutions. They live within families and communities, and Compassion's programs operate through local churches.
These children may already be surrounded by parents, grandparents, siblings, teachers, pastors, and neighbors who know them intimately and care deeply about their futures. Their primary needs may be economic and educational rather than a lack of personal love or affirmation.
I wonder whether a correspondence model developed for orphaned children in the 1950s has been carried forward without sufficient reconsideration of whether it is equally appropriate for the children and families Compassion serves today.
A practice that was especially valuable in one historical context should not be considered indispensable simply because it has become part of an organization's identity.
An alternative: Sponsoring communities rather than individual children
After our sponsored child graduated from the program, I chose not to sponsor again. Instead, I redirected our charitable giving to World Vision's Child Health and Nutrition Fund.
I wanted to continue supporting children without requiring a personal benefactor-beneficiary relationship.
I believe Compassion could consider a similar approach while preserving much of what makes its ministry distinctive.
For example, donors might sponsor a particular program operated by a local church in Haiti. They could receive quarterly updates describing the children served, the educational, nutritional and discipleship programs offered, community celebrations, challenges, prayer requests, and measurable accomplishments.
Photographs could depict program activities without publicly identifying individual children. Updates could come from local program leaders, and sponsors could send occasional messages of encouragement to the community rather than developing private relationships with individual children.
Donors would retain a meaningful connection to a particular place and ministry. Local leaders and parents would remain central to children's lives. Children would receive assistance without being expected to reciprocate personal affection or perform gratitude toward foreign benefactors.
This model could also substantially reduce the safeguarding risks inherent in providing unfamiliar adults with personal access to vulnerable children.
I recognize that Compassion's one-to-one sponsorship model is deeply rooted in its history and organizational identity. I also recognize that changing it would involve significant financial and operational challenges.
But an organization's methods should always remain open to reconsideration when evidence suggests that those methods may create unnecessary harm.
A sincere appeal
I share these reflections not as someone hostile to Compassion, Christian missions, or charitable giving, but as someone who has supported this ministry for much of her life and wants it to flourish.
My hope is that Compassion will approach this moment not primarily as a reputational crisis to be managed, but as an opportunity for meaningful institutional reform.
I urge you to commission an independent safeguarding review, establish clear accountability for addressing the findings, reconsider the risks inherent in personal sponsor-child correspondence and public photographs, and seriously explore alternative sponsorship models.
I also urge you to reconsider the lawsuit against Andrew Vezey. Whistleblowers who raise concerns about children's safety should not have to fear that doing so will result in devastating personal and financial consequences.
Above all, I hope Compassion will listen not only to donors and organizational leaders, but also to sponsored children, former participants, parents, caregivers, and local ministry partners. Their perspectives should be central to any reform.
The children and families served by Compassion deserve material support that strengthens their dignity, autonomy, safety, and existing relationships—not assistance that inadvertently places them under additional emotional obligations or exposes them to unnecessary risks.
I remain grateful for the good Compassion has accomplished over many decades. It is precisely because I believe in the importance of that work that I hope you will respond to these revelations with transparency, humility, and decisive action.
Sincerely,
Rachel Stanton
Certified Trauma-Informed Mental Health Coach
Former Compassion International Sponsor